Full transcript
They Said Death Spiral (Again)
0:00Two weeks ago, strategy sold 32 Bitcoin
0:02and the entire market lost its mind. I
0:05told you right on this show that it was
0:07sensationalism and that Saylor would be
0:09buying again within a week. And then,
0:11the very next week, he bought 1,550
0:14coins. The very next week, at a lower
0:16price. And now, we are in round two. And
0:18if you own Bitcoin, you're being told a
0:20story this week that's engineered to
0:22scare you out of it. STRAT, which is
0:24Strategy's preferred stock, just closed
0:26below $90 for the first time ever since
0:29its launch. And the entire bear case
0:31against Saylor now hangs on a single
0:33word. And that word is forced. That
0:35somehow he was forced to sell billions
0:37of dollars of Bitcoin into the worst
0:39market in 2 years and drag the whole
0:41cycle to its bottom. It's on every
0:43headline, every single thread, and
0:45probably a ton of YouTube videos that
0:46you've seen calling this a death spiral.
0:49But here's the problem, that word is a
0:51lie. Bitcoin's at $64,000 as I record
0:54this. It just bounced off 60,000. And
0:57yeah, the chart looks ugly and the panic
0:59is loud. But the loudest panic almost
1:01always shows up at the floor, [snorts]
1:03not at the ceiling. So, by the end of
Leverage, Reserve, Migration
1:05this video, you're going to see the five
1:06separate things that would each have to
1:08fail before strategy was ever forced to
1:10sell a single coin. The one move that
1:12strategy made this morning that quietly
1:14ended this entire debate. And why this
1:16whole panic is actually the first proof
1:18of a $350 trillion shift into Bitcoin
1:22that almost nobody is talking about.
1:23While the headlines are panicking,
1:25what's unfolding right now stands to be
1:27the single biggest development for
1:28Bitcoin's price over the next several
1:30decades. The people waiting for the FTX
1:32moment of this cycle are not going to
1:34find it here. Let's get into it. So,
1:36here's the road map. I want you to hold
1:38three words in your head for the rest of
1:40this video. Leverage, reserve,
1:42migration. Leverage is what actually
1:44broke this week. Reserve is what
Killing The Panic
1:45strategy did about it. And migration is
1:47the thing that makes this entire panic
1:49look, in hindsight, like one of the best
1:52entry points of this cycle. Leverage,
1:54reserve, migration. Very simple. We're
1:56going to come back to those three again
1:57and again. But first, let me kill the
1:59panic because the story that you're
2:01being sold has a fatal flaw in it. The
2:03bear case goes like this. Stretch trades
2:05below $100. When it's below 100,
2:07strategy can't issue any more of it. So,
2:09the cash spigot that funds Bitcoin buys
2:12shuts off. To push the price back up,
2:14they have to raise the dividend, which
2:15makes the cash that they owe even
2:17bigger. They've been plugging the gap by
2:18selling MicroStrategy common stock, but
2:20that premium has collapsed toward one to
2:22one. So, there's no room left there in
2:25there, which leaves one door, one
2:26mechanism to fund the dividend, and
2:28that's selling Bitcoin. And not a tiny
2:3032-coin trim this time, 5 to 10 billion
2:33dollars worth of forced selling dumped
2:36into a market that's already hanging on
2:37a cliff while Saylor himself drags
2:39Bitcoin to the true bottom of the cycle.
2:41It sounds terrifying, but it's also
2:43built on a word that does not survive
2:45contact with reality, and that is
2:48forced. So, let me show you what
2:49actually happened because it's two
2:51things, and neither of them is the
2:53business is broken, and it certainly
2:55isn't a systemic risk to Bitcoin. The
2:58first thing is a leverage wipeout. For
3:00about 6 months, the story around stretch
3:02became that its volatility was
3:04disappearing. The price spent almost all
3:06of its time pinned between $99 and $100.
3:09And when an asset looks like it's always
3:10going to be north of $95, people do what
3:13people always do. They lever it up. If
Why STRC Actually Dropped
3:16you're certain that the price is going
3:17to hold, you take 20 to one leverage.
3:19You buy a pile of stretch, and you juice
3:21your yield into the stratosphere. That
3:23works great, right? up until it doesn't.
3:26The second that the price slips, the
3:27margin calls hit. Forced selling
3:29triggered more forced selling. That's
3:32not Bitcoin failing or stretch failing.
3:34It's not strategy failing. That is
3:36leveraged gamblers getting flushed out
3:38of a trade that they never understood in
3:39the first place. That is link one,
3:41leverage, and it's important to
3:42understand because that's the entire
3:44thing that drove the sell-off. And
3:46here's the tell. If this were a real
3:48solvency problem for strategy, a
3:50contagion problem for Bitcoin, you would
3:52see it everywhere. You'd see strategies
3:54other preferred collapsing. You'd see
3:55competing products collapsing, but you
3:58don't. On the very same day that Stretch
4:00traded at $89, the competing product
4:02from another Bitcoin treasury company,
4:03Strive, was trading right at par and
4:05paying a 13% dividend. So, if the market
4:08truly believed that 847,000 Bitcoin
4:11couldn't back $10 billion of preferred
4:13stock, there is no universe where a tiny
4:15fraction of that Bitcoin can buy a
4:17smaller stack of preferred at a
4:18competitor and trade at $100. Either
4:21both are broken or neither is. So,
4:23clearly the market is just telling you
4:25that it wants a higher yield. It's
4:27telling you in real time with real
4:28dollars that Stretch is not broken and
4:31Strategy will be forced to sell any
4:32Bitcoin. And here's the part that
4:34matters most, the part that turns this
4:35whole forced seller narrative on its
4:37head. The forced selling that happened
4:39this week was real. People absolutely
4:42were forced to sell, but it wasn't
4:44Strategy. It was the speculators. Let me
4:46walk you through exactly how this trade
4:48worked because once you see it, panic
4:50dissolves. Stretch pays an 11 and 1/2%
4:52yield and for months it barely moved off
4:54of $100. So, again, traders did the
4:58obvious thing. They borrowed money at a
4:59lower interest rate than that yield, say
5:016 or 7%, and then used that borrowed
5:04money to buy Stretch on margin, and then
The Word "Forced" Is A Lie
5:07they pocketed the spread. You borrow at
5:096%, earn an 11 and 1/2%, lever it up,
5:11and you've manufactured a double-digit
5:13return on a thing that supposedly never
5:15moves. It's a carry trade. It's one of
5:17the most popular trades in global
5:18finance, and it's beautiful one. Right
5:21up until the asset moves against you,
5:23even slightly. So, the second that
5:24Stretch ticked down, those leveraged
5:26positions blew past their margin
5:28requirements, the brokers issued margin
5:30calls, and those traders were forced to
5:32dump their Stretch at any price just to
5:34cover. That forced selling drove the
5:37price down further, which triggered the
5:38next round of margin calls, which forced
5:40more selling. This is what's called a
5:42liquidation cascade. And that's the
5:44entire move that that watched last week.
5:46Now, here's the part that you cannot
5:48miss. Every single one of those four
5:51sellers was a leverage speculator. Not a
5:53single one of them was strategy.
5:55Strategy didn't sell a single share.
5:57Their balance sheet didn't change by a
5:59dollar. The people who got margin called
6:01were gamblers who turned a low
6:03volatility yield product into a high
6:05leverage bet. And the market did to them
6:07what it always does. Strategy was a
6:09bystander to its own stock getting
6:11flushed. The thing that bears are
6:13pointing at and calling a death spiral
6:16is just a pile of over-leveraged traders
6:18getting liquidated. And it posed zero
6:20risk to strategy itself, zero. That is a
6:23completely different diagnosis than the
6:25machine is breaking. And by the way,
6:27real quick, before you go any further,
6:28on the last strategy video, a lot of you
6:31called the bottom in the comments before
6:32the bounce. So, comment the word forced
6:35below. Just that word forced. I want to
6:37see who understands by the end of this
6:39video why that word is the biggest lie
6:41in this entire narrative. So, let's
6:42continue. Now, let's talk about that
6:44word forced because the whole bear case
6:47hinges on it. This idea that strategy
6:49was forced to sell. Like it's a death
The Move Strategy Made This Morning
6:51sentence. But here's the math that the
6:53doom criers skip. Before strategy ever
6:55touches a single Bitcoin to fund a
6:57dividend, it has to run through its cash
6:59reserve first. And that brings us to
7:01link two, which is the reserve. This is
7:03the move this morning that quietly ended
7:05the entire debate. The drop in stretch
7:07started last week. The market looked at
7:09strategy's roughly six months of
7:11dividend cash on hand and decided that
7:13it wasn't enough. That was a big part of
7:15why stretch sank all the way down to
7:17$62. So, what did strategy do this
7:20morning? Monday, and if you're not a
7:22channel member, you're watching this on
7:23Tuesday. By the way, channel members got
7:25this video 24 hours early. What did
7:26strategy do on Monday, the start of a
7:28fresh week? They calmly raised about
7:30$335 million in fresh capital and used
7:34most of it to push the USD reserve up by
7:36about $300 million to $1.4 billion.
7:39That takes their dividend coverage from
7:41about six months to roughly 10 months
7:43worth of cash sitting right there before
7:46Bitcoin ever enters the conversation.
7:48And in the same breath, they bought
7:49another 520 Bitcoin, too. So, they
7:51increased the cash cushion and they
7:53stacked more Bitcoin on the same
7:55morning, in the same announcement. Sit
7:57with that for a second. The bears have
7:58been crying that Strategy is about to
8:00collapse imminently. The bear thesis is
8:02that Strategy is a cornered seller, just
8:05one bad week away from liquidating its
8:07entire stack. But in the middle of the
8:09worst sentiment of the entire saga, they
8:11added to the cash pile and added to the
8:13Bitcoin pile simultaneously.
8:15That is not the behavior of a forced
8:17seller. That is the behavior of a
8:18company with the deepest balance sheet
8:20in the entire industry, calmly
8:22responding to a market signal. The
8:24market reaction was immediate. Stretch
8:25went back above $90. Strategy opened the
8:27day up, Bitcoin up. All three were green
8:30on the announcement. Of course, Strategy
8:32then went on to end the day in the red,
8:33but the point remains. And let me put
8:35the forced to sell Bitcoin fear
8:37completely to bed with the actual
8:39numbers. Strategy holds 847,000 Bitcoin,
8:42worth roughly $55 billion.
8:44Their annual dividend obligation across
8:46the entire stack of preferred equities
8:48is about $1.7 billion a year. So, even
8:51if you ignore every other tool they
8:53have, the Bitcoin reserve alone covers
8:55more than 30 years of dividend payments.
8:5730 years. And before they would ever
8:59touch it, they have the cash reserve.
They Survived Worse In 2022
9:01They have MicroStrategy equity issuance.
9:03And they have the ability to issue more
9:04Stretch the moment that it climbs back
9:06over par. They also have traditional
9:08debt markets where they've raised
9:09billions at near zero interest
9:11previously, and they could do it again.
9:13And they have private capital raises.
9:15Selling the Bitcoin is the last resort
9:17behind a stack of five other levers to
9:19pay the dividend. In fact, their balance
9:21sheet is so strong, their leverage ratio
9:23sits below 5%, meaning Bitcoin would
9:26need to crash 95% and stay there for
9:29several years before Strategy was ever a
9:32forced seller of a single Bitcoin. Now,
9:34compare this situation to where Strategy
9:36actually was once before because this is
9:39the part that should end the whole
9:41stablecoin Terra Luna comparison
9:43forever. Back in late 2022, when Bitcoin
9:45fell under $16,000, Strategies debt
9:48exceeded the combined value of its
9:50Bitcoin and cash by about $300 million.
9:53They were genuinely underwater. MSTR
9:56fell into the $13 range. That was a real
9:59stress test with way more debt and way
10:02less cushion than they carry today. And
10:04even then, in that hole, strategy was
10:06not a force seller. They actually
10:08strengthened the company. They raised
10:09over $60 billion more. They added more
10:11than 700,000 Bitcoin into that. Their
10:14reserves exceed their debt by around $48
10:16billion.
10:17They survived the worst spot they were
10:19ever in with a fraction of today's
The $350 Trillion Migration
10:21strength. The sentiment right now is far
10:23worse than the actual situation. And
10:26that gap between how bad it feels and
10:28how strong strategy actually is, that's
10:31the entire opportunity. So, those are
10:33points one and two, leverage and
10:34reserve. The panic was a leverage flush
10:37and the reserve response this morning
10:39proved that the balance sheet was never
10:40the problem. Which brings us to the
10:42third word and this is where this stops
10:44being a story about one stock and
10:47becomes a story about the entire
10:48financial system. And that's migration.
10:51Why does strategy even exist? Why is
10:53Saylor building this elaborate machine
10:54of preferred stocks instead of just
10:56buying Bitcoin and sitting on it? Well,
10:58here's the answer. And it reframes
11:00absolutely everything. There is roughly
11:03$350 trillion of yield seeking capital
11:05in the world. Pension funds, insurance
11:07companies, money market funds, sovereign
11:08wealth funds, retirees who need monthly
11:10income. I can go on. That is the single
11:12largest pool of money on the planet. And
11:15almost none of it can or will buy spot
11:17Bitcoin. It's not allowed to. It's
11:19mandate is income, not a volatile asset
11:21that doesn't pay anything. That capital
11:23has nowhere good to go because every
11:25yield product it currently buys, every
11:27corporate bond, every treasury is built
11:29on the same fragile foundation. A
11:31promise to pay you back out of future
11:33cash flow that may or may not exist in
11:3510 years. What Strategy built is the
11:38bridge. Stretch takes that yield-seeking
11:41money and routes it into Bitcoin, while
11:43paying the holder an 11 and 1/2% yield
11:45backed not by a hope and a prayer about
11:47future earnings, but by an asset that
11:50Strategy already owns today. And
11:52granted, preferred stock holders aren't
11:53actually entitled to any of the Bitcoin,
11:55but the point remains. A Google bond is
11:58a bet that Google still has the cash
11:59flow to pay you in a decade. Strategy,
12:01on the other hand, is backed by a
12:03company that has 847,000 Bitcoin sitting
12:06on the balance sheet right now. One is a
12:08promise, but the other is collateral.
12:11That is a fundamentally different and
12:12more durable thing than anything that
12:14came before it. And that $350 trillion
12:16pool of capital has already started to
12:19move. Bitcoin-backed digital credit went
12:21from $0 to $13 billion in 11 months.
12:25Now, $13 [snorts] billion is still a
12:27rounding error against $350 trillion.
12:29It's a thimble dipped in the ocean. But
12:31the demand for yield never disappears.
12:34It only migrates. And it's started
12:36migrating toward the one yield product
12:38on Earth backed by an asset that can't
12:40be printed, can't be debased, and is
12:42capped at 21 million units forever. That
12:45is the migration. And what you're
12:46watching this week, this whole panic,
12:48the levered flush, the debt spiral
12:50headlines, this is just the first time
12:52that the bridge has been tested. This is
12:54the first real test, and it's holding.
12:57The structure took the hit, the issuer
12:58responded by getting stronger, and the
13:00bridge is still standing. Real quick, I
13:02want to say something to the people
13:03watching who are actually thinking about
13:05retirement, because this whole episode
13:06is about exactly that kind of capital.
13:08If you're someone who wants to retire
Sponsor Segment: Strong Wealth
13:10without selling your Bitcoin and without
13:11handing it to some traditional advisor
13:13who just doesn't get it, this video is
13:15sponsored by Stronghold, who is built
13:16for you. They're Bitcoin-native advisors
13:18who share your worldview. They build a
13:20retirement plan designed around your
13:21Bitcoin, and they run a portfolio
13:23strategy that adapts to whatever the the
13:25regime throws at it. So, no matter what
13:27Bitcoin does next, your retirement is
13:28built for it. Book a free discovery call
13:30at strongwell.net/joe.
13:32That's strongwell.net/joe. Link in the
13:34description. Special thanks to
13:36Strongwell for being a partner of the
13:37channel. Now, back to the migration
What Has To Go Wrong For The Bears
13:39because I want to be honest with you
13:40about both sides of this. Here's what
13:42would have to go wrong for the bears to
13:43be right. Strategy would have to blow
13:46through its $1.4 billion cash reserve
13:48and then fail to raise a single dollar
13:50from MSTR equity and then fail to issue
13:53any stretch and then fail to tap into a
13:55new debt market that is already handing
13:56them billions of dollars at zero cost
13:58and then at the same time as all of
13:59that, watch Bitcoin crash 95% and stay
14:02there for years. Every single one of
14:04those failures has to happen in sequence
14:06before the Bitcoin reserve even enters
14:08the conversation about potentially
14:10needing to be sold. That is the long
14:12sequence of dominoes that this death
14:14spiral story quietly skips over. The
14:16reality isn't telling you strategy is
14:18one bad week from selling, it's telling
14:20you strategy is one bad week followed by
14:23five separate catastrophic failures from
14:25needing to sell. So, when you say it out
14:27loud, the whole narrative of a death
14:29spiral and strategy being a forced
14:31seller of Bitcoin and more importantly,
14:33strategy posing a systemic risk to
14:34Bitcoin completely falls apart. And
14:36here's what I think actually happens
14:38from here, which is the part that the
14:39panic is blinding people to. I think
14:41stretch drifts back towards par as the
14:43leverage finishes flushing. Anyone who
14:45bought near $82 last week is probably
14:47sitting on a double digit capital gain
14:49on the way back to 100 plus an effective
14:51yield north of 13% locked in at a
14:53discount. The people who panicked sold
14:55the bottom of a leverage cascade to the
14:57people who understood that it was a
14:59leverage cascade. That's how every one
Strategy Is Not A Systemic Risk
15:01of these things work. And there's one
15:02more thing that I have to address
15:04because the loudest version of the bear
15:05case claims that strategy is a systemic
15:07risk to Bitcoin itself.
15:09Let me be clear, it isn't. Even in the
15:11absolute worst case, even if strategy
15:13sold every single Bitcoin it owns out of
15:15the open market tomorrow, which I've
15:17discussed why that's not going to
15:18happen, Bitcoin would not die. The price
15:21would fall, sure, but the network
15:23wouldn't even flinch. Strategy and
15:25BlackRock combined are custodians for
15:26around 7 and 1/2% of all the Bitcoin
15:28that exists. The other 92% doesn't care.
15:32Here's the thing about Bitcoin that the
15:33panic makes people forget. If Bitcoin
15:35could be killed by a company that liked
15:37it enough to buy too much of it, then it
15:38was never going to work in the first
15:40place. The fact that one buyer cannot
15:42break it is the entire point. So, let me
15:45bring this home. We have leverage
15:46reserve migration. Those are the three
15:48words I told you to hold on to you at
15:50the start of the video. The panic last
15:52week was a leverage flush, plain and
15:53simple. A pile of speculators getting
15:55margin called, and it had nothing to do
15:57with Strategy's actual health. The
15:59reserve response this morning, raising
16:01cash to 10 months of coverage while
16:03buying more Bitcoin in the same breath,
16:05proved that the balance sheet was never
16:06a weak point. And the migration, the
16:08slow rotation of $350 trillion of
16:11yield-seeking capital toward
16:12Bitcoin-backed credit, is the real
16:14story. And it just passed its first live
The Sound Of A Bottom
16:17stress test. Strategy sold 32 Bitcoin
16:19and bought back 48 times that amount the
16:22very next week. They watched stretch
16:24fall and responded by getting stronger.
16:27Every move the bears have called a sign
16:29of weakness has been the machine running
16:31exactly as designed. And real quick, I
16:33want to say thank you because if you're
16:35still with me this far in the video,
16:36you're exactly the kind of person this
16:38channel is built for. Around 84% of you
16:40watching right now aren't subscribed
16:42yet. So, if you're getting value out of
16:44this, hit that subscribe button, drop a
16:45like, hit the bell, and turn on
16:47notifications so you catch these
16:48breakdowns the moment that they go live.
16:50It genuinely helps the channel more than
16:52you know, and real quick, I've also been
16:54building a community for serious Bitcoin
16:56holders, a weekly round table discussion
16:58with me, written briefs, and a small
17:00group of people who actually think about
17:01this stuff at the level we just went
17:03through. The waitlist is open now. It's
17:05at the link in the description. Sign up
17:06to know when it goes live, and founding
17:08members get pricing locked in for life.
17:10Now, back to it. The people screaming
17:13death spiral this week are about to
17:14learn the same lesson they refused to
17:16learn 2 weeks ago. When the loudest
17:18panic comes from the people who used to
What Comes Next
17:20be the biggest believers, that's not the
17:22sound of something breaking, that is the
17:23sound of a bottom. All of this
17:25infighting between Bitcoiners tends to
17:27happen when Bitcoin is close to a
17:29bottom. I told you 2 weeks ago that 32
17:31coins wasn't a surrender, and a week
17:34later Saylor bought 1,550. This week,
17:37I'm telling you that an 8% drawdown in
17:3911-month-old credit instrument in the
17:41middle of a rate shock is not a death
17:43spiral. It is a bridge taking its first
17:46test and staying on its feet. If you
17:48want to understand the rate shock that
17:50I'm referencing and why chances are
17:52we're not going to get any rate hikes
17:53this year, but we're probably going to
17:55get rate cuts, go watch my last video
17:57because this is a direct sequel to it,
17:59and it'll make everything that I just
18:00said click even further into place.
18:02That's linked right there, and I'll see
18:03you over there. Channel members got this
18:05video 24 hours early, so hit the join
18:07button down below to support the channel
18:09and become a member. And if you haven't
18:10already, subscribe to the channel and
18:12hit the bell to get notified whenever a
18:13new video goes live. Hit the link at the
18:15top of the description to join the wait
18:16list for my community and book a
18:17one-on-one session with me at the link
18:19in the description. I'll see you in the
18:20next one.