Full transcript
Eigenheim vs. Miete: Was lohnt sich mehr?
0:00Hey Roman , we're moving into a rental
0:02house . Many advise against it because
0:04of the high rent and say it's better to
0:06buy . 550,000 purchase price versus
0:101,650 base rent . With the same loan
0:13rate of 4 % over 30 years , about 200,000
0:16in equity is needed . We prefer to put
0:19our equity into Bitcoin . What's your
0:22opinion on this example ? The thing is ,
0:34why many say , " buy instead , " is a
0:36simple calculation : you have a monthly
0:38payment and in the end , the place
0:39potentially belongs to you . The only
0:42problem is that the math doesn't quite
0:43add up . Sure , you might have that
0:46appreciation inherent to a property ,
0:49but you also have a significantly
0:51higher payment or a very high amount of
0:54equity you have to put in . Now you have
0:57to ask yourself the following . You put
0:59200,000 euros into something that
1:01potentially , let's say , over the next
1:0430 years , quadruples or quintuples ,
1:07which would already be enormous . It
1:10probably won't be that strong , but
1:12let's assume something strong over 30
1:14years . Then you still paid interest on
1:17the property the whole time . You had to
1:20modernize it and in the end , you
1:22couldn't invest those 200,000 euros in
1:24something else . In this case , Bitcoin .
1:27In 30 years , a lot can happen . Bitcoin
1:31has already increased a hundredfold in
1:33the last 9 years . So what happens in 30
1:37years ? And then you see very quickly ,
1:39it's very likely not that smart to put
1:42your equity into a property . And if you
1:45don't do it with equity — there's the
1:47other calculation — then you have a
1:48much higher monthly payment for the
1:50sake of having a home , and you're still
1:52likely pouring money into it the whole
1:54time , because everything that breaks ,
1:56if you rent , is not your problem but
1:58the landlord's , and if you buy , it's on
2:00you . A window pane breaks , you have to
2:02repair it yourself . The heating breaks ,
2:03you have to repair it yourself . Windows
2:05are drafty , you have to repair them
2:06yourself . All that constantly costs
2:08money and it can get really expensive ,
2:10especially when you look at inflation
2:12and above all the politically uncertain
2:15situation , like what heating systems am
2:17I allowed to install and so on , what
2:19requirements do I have , and it doesn't
2:22stop there . You then pay property tax
2:24and all sorts of other stuff that comes
2:26with it . And that is , of course , a
2:29permanent burden , and especially when
2:30you live in it yourself , a property
2:32simply isn't worth it in most cases .
2:34You have to say that quite clearly ,
2:37even if it has an increase in value .
Die Vorteile eines Eigenheims
2:41The advantage of real estate , and I
2:42don't want to downplay this , is that
2:43you can borrow money for this type of
2:45property . You just don't get a few
2:47hundred thousand euros for Bitcoin , but
2:49you can get that for a property from
2:51the bank . And that can still be worth
2:54it in that sense , because you say , "
2:56Look , I'm getting the money now and can
2:59buy something that might be scarce , and
3:01I didn't even have to take it from my
3:03own account . " But as you've already
3:05noted , it's not that simple . You still
3:07have to put down a lot of equity or
3:09reach much deeper into your pockets
3:11every month . So from this perspective ,
3:16if you are convinced by Bitcoin ,
3:17Bitcoin will be the much better deal by
3:19far . By far . I don't want to talk down
3:23anyone's home ownership , because I
3:25believe that owning a home also
3:26provides a different quality of life ,
3:28and that can be worth it to you . It
3:31depends a bit on your personal
3:32situation . Let's say you have 3 million
3:36in savings . Why not spend a little and
3:41say , " Fine , I know that if push comes
3:43to shove , the state could theoretically
3:46confiscate it . " I know I have a monthly
3:49installment to pay the bank and I have
3:51to put in my own equity , but it might
3:54be worth it to you to have that feeling
3:56of a home , to be able to do what you
3:58want , to fix it up how you like ,
4:00without having to answer to anyone ,
4:02like a landlord , if you change the
4:05walls or whatever else . Therefore , I
4:07think a property should be seen less as
4:09an investment product if you live in it
4:11yourself , and more as a consumer and
4:13luxury good . And I have nothing against
4:17consumer and luxury goods . One should
4:19just buy these things with that
4:21awareness , provided you aren't already
4:22in that kind of financial position .
Die Nachteile eines Eigenheims
4:24From a financial perspective , a
4:26property you live in yourself can be
4:28quite dangerous . If you buy a property
4:32to rent it out , and you manage to get a
4:35100 % mortgage — though you don't really
4:38get those anymore — but if you have a
4:40100 % mortgage and can cover your entire
4:43monthly payment through rental income ,
4:45and maybe even a little extra to cover
4:48any potential repairs , then it might
4:51make sense , even though it is still
4:53subject to various risks . You also have
4:56to ask yourself at this point , wouldn't
4:59it be smarter to try and buy Bitcoin
5:01instead ? But as I said , a bank just
5:03won't give you money to buy Bitcoin .
5:05They will for buying real estate , but
5:07property is just a lot of work . You
5:08have to take care of it , repair it ,
5:10maintain it , and you have tenants who
5:12always have various little issues .
5:14These are all things you’ll have to
5:16put time into , and eventually , being a
5:17landlord becomes a job . Bitcoin doesn't
5:20make you or force you into that job .
5:23Bitcoin has no frequency . It requires
Warum Bitcoin so unkompliziert ist
5:25no maintenance . You don't have to
5:26constantly do things or keep up with it
5:28. You don't have to keep dumping money
5:30back into it to keep it running . Yes ,
5:32it doesn't just suddenly fall apart .
5:34And aside from that , the regulatory
5:35clarity is pretty straightforward .
5:37Especially because if Bitcoin doesn't
5:39move , there are no taxes or anything
5:40else to pay . No property taxes or
5:43anything else makes Bitcoin the
5:46superior asset from an investment
5:49perspective . I think it's also
5:52difficult to explain that to someone
5:54who can't really relate to the digital
5:56world . It's also very difficult to
5:59explain it to someone who has already
6:01made a lot of money in the classic real
6:03estate world and is very successful
6:04there . For that person , it is much
6:08easier to add the next , and next , and
6:11next property to a portfolio of 40
6:13existing units than it is for someone
6:16buying their first property to live in
6:18and seeing it as a smart investment .
6:22That just doesn't add up . So , I think a
6:24property you live in yourself is always
6:26a kind of luxury good . There's nothing
6:28wrong with that , as long as you aren't
6:30buying it for the sake of capital
6:31appreciation . Then , in the best-case
6:33scenario , the appreciation might
6:35eventually cover what you put into it .
6:37Uh , and maybe cover the taxes you paid
6:40and the purchasing power lost to
6:42inflation over time , but from an
6:44investment standpoint , it would have
6:47probably always been smarter to buy
6:49good asset classes like Bitcoin instead
6:52. This isn't meant to be investment
6:54advice , but simply to provide a few
6:56more thoughts on the topic so that you
6:58can perhaps make your decision more
7:00rationally . And I'm completely with you
7:02there , Lachsfarben . If you have 200,000
7:05euros available right now in a bear
7:08market and could put it into Bitcoin
7:10compared to a real estate market that
7:13has already developed very strongly in
7:15recent years , then it can quickly mean
7:18that just by waiting one or two years ,
7:20you might turn that 200,000 into 400 or
7:23600,000 and then think to yourself : "
7:26Now I could still buy the property ,
7:28right ? " And up to that point , I’ll
7:31have maybe paid , I don’t know , €
7:3325,000 in rent . It’s not the end of
7:35the world . I’ll make that back
7:36quickly . I mean , investing € 200,000
7:39in a house is no small sum , but since
7:42it’s only a fraction of the cost and
7:44the growth potential of real estate
7:46isn’t that strong anymore — well ,
7:48that depends a bit on the area . Are you
7:51in a super high-demand area in a big
7:54city or out in the countryside ? There
7:57are obviously completely different
7:59trends from one place to another , but
8:00in most cases , if you look at houses
8:02that are currently still affordable ,
8:04you're usually entering areas that
8:06aren't developing quite as quickly . But
8:08yeah , we don't know that for sure , of
8:10course . Uh , there are a few other
8:12points to consider , especially when it
8:14comes to real estate and demographic
Demografischer Wandel als Risiko für Immobilien
8:16change . Japan is a good example where
8:18you can see that for yourself . Japan
8:20has special regulations , though . Be
8:21careful , you aren't allowed to buy real
8:23estate in Japan as a foreigner . There
8:25always has to be a Japanese person
8:27involved . That’s what I’ve heard ,
8:30anyway . Uh , but that’s a different
8:31topic . Their biggest problem is
8:33demographic change . They have problems
8:35with birth rates too . That means there
8:37are more and more older people who are
8:39now passing away . So , more and more
8:41people are leaving , and fewer young
8:42people are coming up to take their
8:44place . And the entire Japanese economy
8:46is at risk of collapsing due to this
8:48issue , especially the real estate
8:50market , because all those properties
8:52can't find buyers , and when no buyers
8:54are found , prices drop . And a phase
8:57like the one we're in now , where real
8:59estate prices have already risen
9:00sharply , coupled with a birth rate of
9:021.3 or so children per woman , doesn't
9:06make for a very attractive environment
9:09for buying real estate over a 30 - year
9:11perspective . Yes , we have a lot of
9:13migration and similar topics , bringing
9:15many people into the country from
9:16outside , but whether they will be in a
9:18position to buy those properties , keep
9:20the rates up , and so on , is a
9:21completely different matter . And
9:23whether that will even last . So , it’s
9:25no guarantee that it will work out .
9:28There are actually two problems to
9:30overcome . One is keeping the property
9:32maintained and valuable . The other is ,
9:35of course , keeping an eye on a
9:37country's birth rates and getting the
9:39country back on track . And that can
9:41take decades . So , I simply consider the
9:43real estate market in the current
9:45situation to be significantly riskier
9:47than a Bitcoin investment . uh , simply
9:49for these reasons mentioned , without
9:50giving any investment advice or
9:52anything , just from a perspective
9:53standpoint . Yeah , even if you don't use
9:55any equity , right ? Let's say you
9:58currently have 1650 euros in base rent
10:00and would have a payment plus interest
10:03instead . Um , I guess if I calculate
10:07that , 4 % — probably about 3000 euros or
10:10so that you would have to pay , probably
10:12around double . Even just starting a
10:18savings plan now and taking that
10:20monthly difference of 1300 euros or so
10:27and starting to put it into Bitcoin , it
10:28will pay off more in the long run than
10:30owning the property after 30 years . By
10:33the way , if you want to buy Bitcoin and
10:35not through a broker , but through an
10:37exchange with a few more features , then
10:39feel free to check out Bitvavo . The
10:42advantage of Bitvavo is that they have
10:43been established on the market for many
10:45years . You can , of course , also
10:47withdraw the Bitcoin you purchased
10:48there . But you have the advantage that
10:51the purchase is very cheap , because you
10:52are buying directly on the exchange ,
10:54and the sign-up process is very simple .
10:57Other benefits are , above all , that you
10:59can even deposit here with PayPal and
11:00that you get a welcome bonus of 10
11:02euros . All of this via our link in the
11:04video description . Which , of course ,
11:06also supports our work .