Free YouTube Transcribe

Video transcript

India’s Rape Response is Wrong | Faye D'Souza

Faye D'Souza · 1,451 words · 7 min read

Want to search this transcript, jump the video from any line, or download it as TXT, SRT, or VTT?

Open in the transcript tool

Full transcript

0:00So a girl was raped in a park in Delhi

0:02and our response was to shut the park.

0:06When women face violence in public

0:07spaces, why is it that our response is

0:09to restrict their freedom even further?

0:11Take a look at today's achievements

0:13gloriously in our country in Uttar

0:14Pradesh. Two police officers and two

0:16CRPF personnel called a w woman to a

0:19farmhouse and took turns to rape her.

0:21They've now been arrested in Bihar after

0:22that Jammu incident. Another incident in

0:26Samastipur where men surrounded and

0:28harassed a girl who was out with a boy

0:30in Delhi. After that 17-year-old was

0:33raped on her birthday in a park, the

0:36nearby women's college, LSR moved its

0:40classes online, the Delhi Development

0:41Authority decided to control entry to

0:43parks after sunset. So the message being

0:45sent is that when there is violence

0:48against girls, girls must stay home,

0:49classes will move online, access to

0:51parks will be restricted. So the men who

0:53actually inflicted that violence, not

0:56only did they take away that one girl's

0:58freedom, the loss is permanent now for

1:00all girls. India's problem really and we

1:04keep asking why does this happen? Why do

1:05we have a problem of sexual assault in

1:07India is because we have a deeply

1:09unequal society

1:11and in that unequal society from birth

1:14the value of a girl is judged based on

1:16her virginity which is her market value

1:19for marriage. So irrespective of her

1:21talents and her ambition and her

1:23achievements and her dreams, her final

1:26goal is to be owned by a man and only a

1:28good virgin girl can be married. So a

1:32girl who steps out, god forbid, late at

1:34night dressed provocatively with a man

1:36has obviously decided [gasps] to gamble

1:38away her virginity

1:41and her eligibility for marriage. And

1:42therefore now any two bit chap on the

1:44street decides he can help himself to

1:46her. Men are never required to justify

1:49their clothes, their company, their

1:50ambition, their location in the context

1:52of social morality. And women have to

1:54constantly live in fear.

1:57What if I miss the bus? What if I end up

1:59in a dark street? What if the street

2:00light goes out? What if the library is

2:02shut? What if I don't get an auto? What

2:04if the metro is not available? And of

2:06course, the Indian classic, what if I'm

2:07raped on a bus? We keep coming back to

2:09that classic on a regular basis. Society

2:12has a sthing anger, a sthing, deep anger

2:16for girls who dare to break the rules,

2:18who go out to study, for tuution in a

2:20t-shirt with a boy. Oh my god,

2:25the hatred for those girls who symbolize

2:28an ambition to unshackle their necks, to

2:31break the chains, to live in a world

2:33where perhaps they don't need a husband

2:35or his Tawi's approval to survive.

2:39Men hate those girls. Those girls

2:41threaten their very existence, threaten

2:44the value of their existence. And women

2:47who have access to money, women who have

2:49access to wealth are able to insulate

2:51themselves because they buy cars. They

2:54choose different routes. They book

2:55camps.

2:57They hire drivers. They hire security

2:59guards. They choose a more expensive

3:01place to live. They decide because they

3:03can. They decide when they can go out

3:05and when they don't want to go out. A

3:06study done in India in 2019 on um urban

3:10mobility showed that on the day that

3:12they were asked 53% of the women uh in

3:15urban India said that they had not

3:17stepped out of their house but that

3:18number was only 14% for the men. So

3:21obviously women and men don't have equal

3:23access to life outside the home. Half

3:25our population are not able to

3:27participate. You can put a guard at the

3:29gate but you cannot change the mindset

3:31in our society where men feel entitled

3:34to decide where a woman belongs and then

3:37they feel entitled to punish a woman who

3:38has gone against their personal

3:40decision. If we intended to solve the

3:43problem as a country like really

3:45intended to solve the problem like we

3:47really meant it. There's enough research

3:48to tell us what to do because there is

3:50all of this like oh how do we stop the

3:51rapes from happening? We don't know how

3:53to stop the rapes from happening. We

3:55know how to stop the rapes from

3:56happening. We just don't want to do

3:57anything about it. First of all, we have

3:59to give women their spaces back, all

4:02their spaces at all times of the day,

4:03which means make the buses more

4:05reliable, the streets well lit, the

4:07parks well-maintained. Appoint women to

4:09solve these problems on a roadby basis

4:12across the country on priority. Ask the

4:15women who use the spaces what they need.

4:17Where do they need the lights? Where do

4:18they need the help? What needs to be

4:20solved? And measure the outcomes clearly

4:23by the numbers of women who can travel,

4:25by the ones who can work, who can spend

4:27time outside their home in leisure. So

4:29they're going out of their house after

4:31dark to enjoy themselves and not because

4:34they have no choice. These numbers,

4:37these outcomes can actually be measured.

4:39Second, we have to teach consent and

4:41equality on everyday principles. From

4:44childhood, boys must be told that girls

4:47are full people.

4:50These are full citizens of these of the

4:52country. They are full people. A woman

4:54decides what she wears, where she goes,

4:56how she studies, when she comes home,

4:58how she comes home, and who she spends

4:59time with. The refusal does not require

5:01an explanation. And being in public is

5:04never permission to touch her, to

5:05threaten her, to interrogate her.

5:09For boys to believe

5:12that women are entitled to consent and

5:16to autonomy, men have to believe it

5:18first. And the men who are the

5:20politicians, the men who are the judges,

5:22the men who are the cops, the men who

5:23are the teachers,

5:26they have to believe it first. We have

5:28to decide that we will punish violation

5:32of consent, harassment and rape anywhere

5:36in this country. Whether we are

5:38eyewitnesses, employers, teachers,

5:40members of the law and order, members of

5:42society, if we see someone harassing a

5:45girl or a woman, we will step up and we

5:47will stop it immediately. We will treat

5:49it as if someone is sitting down when

5:51the national anthem is played. We will

5:53get that angry. We will stop it as soon

5:56as we see it. And that is the only way

5:58to go forward. And I think that there is

6:00a fundamental fault line in what people

6:02have understood.

6:05Women in India are asking for safety.

6:07We're not asking for protection.

6:13That difference is the fault line in our

6:15society because men believe

6:17that they have to bestow on us their

6:20protection

6:22and they will bestow their protection

6:24only on women who are deserving of it.

6:26So women who are good girls, who wear

6:29modest clothes and who are home before

6:31dark and who use polite language so as

6:34to not cause culture shocks, that women

6:37and girls will earn your protection.

6:40So we've created a society where women

6:44need to be protected from men by men who

6:48will decide whether or not [snorts] they

6:51will protect you. And that entire

6:53concept is false because we're not

6:55asking for your protection. We're asking

6:58for safety and safety and the right to

7:00life is guaranteed to us by the

7:03constitution of India irrespective of

7:05our gender also irrespective of our

7:07clothes and our choices and our company

7:09and our location. We still have a right

7:12to life. You don't get to decide that.

7:16And that is the concept of autonomy, of

7:20equality, and of consent

7:23that we fail to recognize as a society

7:26and as a country.

7:30We will see these knee-jerk reactions in

7:33Delhi. There will be cops crawling the

7:35streets for the next 6 days until they

7:36they all just move on to do VIP security

7:38again. They will close the parks and

7:41they will like put banan dark windows on

7:45cars and other knee-jerk reactions that

7:47we have done. Police shooting people in

7:50the foot.

7:52But the real work, the real work is when

7:55the men in power decide

7:58that we are equal.

8:00And here's the thing,

8:04the girls are already going out of their

8:05homes. The girls are studying. They're

8:08becoming scientists. They're becoming

8:09doctors. They're becoming lawyers.

8:11They're becoming judges.

8:13They're not going to go back into the

8:15box.

8:17It's a matter of time.

8:20The men are going to have to get with

8:22the

Recently added transcripts

Browse the whole transcript library

This transcript was generated from the captions YouTube publishes for this video. Get the transcript of any YouTube video atfreeyoutubetranscribe.com, free, unlimited, no sign-up.